Published on:

Data Breach Lawsuits

By

Data breaches have increasingly become one of the most alarming threats to both individuals and organizations. Sensitive personal and health information is often stored electronically, making it a prime target for hackers and cybercriminals.

Recent data breach investigations involving Center for Vein Restoration, Iowa Radiologic Medical Services, Atlantic Orthopaedic Specialists, Rocky Mountain Gastroenterology, Liberty First Credit Union, Anna Jaques Hospital, and an employment-related investigation at Channahon Lion Electric highlight the significant legal and financial repercussions organizations face when cybersecurity measures fail.

The Center for Vein Restoration

The Maryland-based Center for Vein Restoration (CFVR) announced a data breach that compromised the sensitive personal and protected health information of 446,094 individuals. This incident has raised concerns about the security of sensitive data entrusted to CFVR.

On October 6, 2024, CFVR identified a security breach within its IT network. In response, the organization promptly initiated an investigation with the assistance of third-party cybersecurity experts to assess the nature and scope of the attack. The investigation revealed that sensitive personal and protected health data, along with certain employment information, may have been exposed during the incident.

This is a big one—there could be up to 446,094 victims.

Iowa Radiologic Medical Services Data Breach

The Iowa Radiologic Medical Services (IRMS) data breach has left thousands of patients vulnerable, with sensitive information such as medical records, Social Security numbers, and billing data exposed.

On November 11, 2024, Radiologic Medical Services, P.C., the parent company of Corridor Radiology and Muscatine Radiology, reported a data breach to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office for Civil Rights. The breach occurred after unauthorized access to two employee email accounts between February 22 and March 19, 2024, potentially exposing sensitive patient information contained in emails and attachments. After securing the accounts, Radiologic Medical Services worked with cybersecurity experts to investigate the incident, identify affected individuals, and assess the compromised data. On September 13, 2024, the company completed its review and began sending personalized data breach notification letters to impacted individuals in November.

The breach underscores the risks of unauthorized access to sensitive healthcare data, including potential identity theft or fraud. Radiologic Medical Services, which oversees Corridor Radiology in Coralville, IA, and Muscatine Radiology in Muscatine, IA, employs over 35 people and provides radiological services such as CT scans, MRIs, and X-rays. Those affected by the breach are encouraged to review their notification letters for details on the compromised data and consider seeking legal advice to protect against potential risks and explore legal options.

Lawyers (not our law firm, by the way) are investigating whether IRMS failed to meet the stringent cybersecurity standards required by laws like the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). Patients impacted by this healthcare data breach may face risks such as identity theft and medical fraud. If you were affected, it’s critical to monitor your financial and medical accounts closely and stay informed about any legal settlements or class actions resulting from this incident.

Atlantic Orthopaedic Specialists Data Breach

Atlantic Orthopaedic Specialists (AOS), headquartered in Virginia Beach, Virginia, with additional locations in Chesapeake and Norfolk, is under scrutiny following a significant data breach that compromised sensitive patient information, including protected health information (PHI). This incident highlights the growing cybersecurity challenges faced by healthcare organizations and the serious consequences for patients when data protection measures fail.

Investigators are now examining whether AOS implemented adequate safeguards to protect patient data and whether it complied with state and federal notification requirements for data breaches. These breaches are more than just administrative headaches—they expose patients to risks of identity theft, fraud, and the unauthorized use of their medical information. The legal and regulatory fallout from this breach will likely set important precedents for how healthcare providers handle similar incidents in the future.

Between June 20 and August 6, 2024, an unauthorized party accessed a corporate email account at AOS. This breach compromised the personal information of more than 15,000 individuals. The exposed data included names, Social Security numbers, medical records, health insurance details, and in some cases, financial information. While AOS reports that it has no evidence of data misuse so far, the implications of this breach are troubling. Can you imagine the anxiety of discovering that your most sensitive personal information might now be in the hands of bad actors?

In response to the breach, AOS engaged third-party cybersecurity experts to investigate the incident, secured the affected account, and reviewed the compromised files to assess the extent of the exposure. Notification letters were sent to affected individuals in late November, and those whose Social Security numbers were exposed were offered complimentary credit monitoring services.

The breach appears to have been triggered by unauthorized access to a single email account—often the result of a phishing attack or inadequate security protocols. It only takes one small vulnerability, like a single successful phishing email, to open the door for a breach. These incidents underscore the need for healthcare organizations to invest in comprehensive cybersecurity training for employees and robust technical safeguards, such as two-factor authentication and real-time intrusion monitoring.

Rocky Mountain Gastroenterology Data Breach

Rocky Mountain Gastroenterology (RMG), based in Littleton, Colorado, with multiple locations throughout the state, has become the latest healthcare provider facing scrutiny after a significant data breach exposed sensitive patient records. This breach highlights the growing threat of cyberattacks targeting healthcare organizations, which store vast amounts of personal and medical information. Cybersecurity experts and legal investigators are raising concerns about whether RMG had implemented adequate protections, such as encryption and intrusion detection systems, to prevent such an incident.

Reports indicate that unauthorized parties accessed the sensitive information of over 150,000 patients, with records spanning from 2015 to 2019. The compromised data includes a wide range of personal identifiers and medical information, such as names, Social Security numbers, dates of birth, addresses, phone numbers, email addresses, medical records, and health insurance details. The breadth and sensitivity of this information make the breach particularly concerning, as it opens the door to risks like identity theft, medical fraud, and financial scams.

Liberty First Credit Union Data Breach

The Liberty First Credit Union, based in Lincoln, Nebraska, has suffered a data breach that compromised the financial and personal information of an undisclosed number of customers. This breach exposes victims to serious risks, including identity theft and financial fraud, underscoring the vulnerabilities in the financial services industry. Legal experts are now investigating whether Liberty First Credit Union failed to comply with consumer protection laws, such as the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, which requires financial institutions to implement safeguards to protect customer data.

The breached data reportedly includes sensitive financial information, leaving affected customers at heightened risk of unauthorized transactions and fraudulent activities. If you believe you may have been impacted, you have to consider doing the annoying things you must to protect yourself. Consider placing a freeze on your credit to prevent unauthorized access, closely monitoring your account activity for suspicious transactions, and taking advantage of any credit monitoring services offered by the credit union.

Anna Jaques Hospital Data Breach

Anna Jaques Hospital, located in Newburyport, Massachusetts, has fallen victim to a cyberattack that exposed the medical and insurance records of numerous patients. This breach has raised significant privacy and cybersecurity concerns, with legal investigations now focusing on whether the hospital adhered to its obligations under HIPAA and other privacy laws designed to protect patient data.

The compromised data could leave victims vulnerable to medical identity theft, unauthorized access to their health information, and fraudulent use of their insurance details. As healthcare data breaches become more frequent, incidents like this highlight the critical need for hospitals to invest in advanced cybersecurity measures. Victims of this breach should closely monitor their medical and financial accounts for any unusual activity and consider taking steps such as placing fraud alerts or freezing their credit.

Channahon Lion Electric Layoff

The recent Channahon Lion Electric investigation has raised questions about potential violations of the Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) Act following a round of layoffs. This is a one-off—this was not a traditional data breach. This case focuses on employment law compliance, specifically whether the company provided the legally required notice to employees before terminating their positions. Under the WARN Act, employers must give at least 60 days’ advance notice of mass layoffs in certain circumstances, ensuring workers have time to prepare for the transition.

Legal experts are now scrutinizing Lion Electric’s actions to determine if the layoffs complied with federal and state labor laws. The investigation underscores the broader importance of corporate responsibility and adherence to legal requirements during workforce reductions. Mass layoffs can significantly impact employees and their families, making compliance with labor laws a critical aspect of ethical business practices. While this case doesn’t involve cybersecurity, it highlights how corporate decisions can trigger serious legal and reputational consequences.

Thompson Coburn LLP/ Presbyterian Healthcare Services

A proposed class action lawsuit was filed this month in a Missouri federal court, accusing U.S. law firm Thompson Coburn LLP and its client, Presbyterian Healthcare Services, of failing to adequately protect sensitive personal and medical information. The lawsuit stems from a May 2024 data breach in which an unknown hacker accessed Thompson Coburn’s network.

The plaintiff claims the firm held his personal data while providing legal services to Presbyterian and notified him of the breach in November. Exposed information reportedly includes names and medical details, such as prescription and clinical data. The lawsuit attributes the breach to inadequate cybersecurity measures by both parties

What Do Data Breach Lawsuits Typically Look Like?

In the world of digital information, data breaches have become a grim reality. Whether it’s your medical records, financial details, or even something as basic as your email address, when your personal information is compromised, the ripple effects can be devastating. You’ve probably seen headlines about high-profile breaches—massive corporations scrambling to contain fallout. But have you ever wondered what happens behind the scenes when a data breach lawsuit unfolds? Let’s peel back the layers of these complex legal battles.

Setting the Scene: How Data Breach Lawsuits Begin

Data breach lawsuits often start with a simple, unfortunate event: someone discovers their sensitive information has been leaked or stolen. It might be an individual receiving a letter saying, “We regret to inform you…” or a large group of people realizing their information has been part of a massive cyberattack. For businesses, it can mean their name splashed across headlines, stock prices plummeting, and angry customers demanding answers.

The first step? Affected individuals (or plaintiffs, as they’ll soon be known in court) team up, often through class action lawsuits. These plaintiffs claim that the breached entity failed to protect their data adequately or respond quickly enough once the breach was discovered. The defendants—usually companies, hospitals, or financial institutions—immediately find themselves on the defensive. Did they use reasonable security measures? Did they delay notifying customers? These are the early questions that frame the case.

The Legal Framework: What Are Plaintiffs Claiming?

Data breach lawsuits typically hinge on a few key legal theories:

  1. Negligence: Plaintiffs argue that the company didn’t take reasonable steps to safeguard their information. Maybe firewalls weren’t up to industry standards, or employees weren’t properly trained to spot phishing attacks.  The latter argument is not the strongest in these cases.
  2. Breach of Contract: Many companies promise in their privacy policies to keep customer data secure. When a breach occurs, plaintiffs might claim that those promises were broken.
  3. Statutory Violations: Depending on the jurisdiction, companies may be accused of violating state or federal privacy laws. For instance, laws like HIPAA (in healthcare) or the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (for financial institutions) impose strict requirements on how sensitive data must be handled.
  4. Unjust Enrichment: Plaintiffs might argue that companies profited from collecting or using their data but failed to reinvest enough into securing it.

Discovery: Where the Real Drama Unfolds

Discovery in a data breach lawsuit is where things get interesting. Plaintiffs demand records, logs, and internal communications. How did the breach happen? Did the company know about vulnerabilities beforehand? Did it cut corners on cybersecurity to save money? These revelations often shape the trajectory of the case.

For companies, this phase is nerve-wracking. Imagine having internal emails dissected line by line, with attorneys asking why an obvious vulnerability wasn’t patched. It’s not just about the breach itself but the decisions leading up to it.

The Role of Class Actions

Data breaches often affect thousands—or millions—of people. Instead of each person filing a separate lawsuit, they often join forces in a class action. This consolidates claims into one case and increases the pressure on companies to settle. For plaintiffs, it’s a chance to hold companies accountable on a larger scale. For defendants, it’s a potential financial nightmare. Settlements can range from millions to hundreds of millions of dollars, depending on the scope of the breach.

Settlements and What Plaintiffs Actually Get

Most data breach lawsuits end in settlements. Rarely do these cases go all the way to trial—there’s simply too much at stake for both sides. Settlements often involve a mix of payouts and non-monetary remedies. Plaintiffs might receive free credit monitoring, identity theft protection, or small cash payments. But here’s the rub: while settlements often sound huge on paper, individual payouts to affected consumers can be relatively modest, especially after attorneys’ fees are deducted.

For companies, settlements are about more than money. They usually involve agreements to improve cybersecurity practices—better encryption, employee training, or regular security audits. These commitments, while not headline-grabbing, are critical to preventing future breaches.

The Human Cost of Data Breaches

Let’s not lose sight of the real people behind these cases. A stolen Social Security number or leaked medical record isn’t just an abstract issue—it’s a personal nightmare. Victims may spend years cleaning up financial messes or battling fraudulent medical claims. The emotional toll? That’s harder to quantify but no less real.